Quick SummaryOnce companies reach a certain size, setting realistic performance aspirations gets a bit trickier.
Living With The Limitations Of Success
That?s why, in our experience, a solid understanding of what kind of performance a big company can really expect from its current business model is an essential starting point for setting performance aspirations in the most effective way. It?s not that large companies can?t do exceedingly well; our research on both US and global market leaders1 reveals that among the top 25 companies by market capitalization, some do continue to outperform the S&P 500 by more than 5 percent.
More telling, for the astute executive, is exactly how they did it. The bottom line: outperformance by large companies is neither easy to achieve nor always at management?s discretion. Among the companies that beat the market after joining the top ranks, all of those that repeated their early success (in value creation and size) did so by sticking to or refining their existing business model. None went beyond or revamped the one that first catapulted them into the top ranks. Furthermore, many that continued to beat the market benefited from factors beyond their immediate control.
Many variables, including economic cycles and degrees of market saturation, help a company to enter the top stratum and remain there. What follows is a closer look at four ways companies outperformed the market?s returns to investors. Our research leads us to believe that even the most successful large companies aren?t likely to outperform over time if they don?t find themselves in one of these situations. The message for executives: be careful about letting pronouncements on performance goals exceed your company?s ability to meet them.
Perfecting the business model
Some companies held onto their top positions for at least a decade by continuing to perfect the business model that made them initially successful?and not going beyond it. This group includes a number of high-tech players, as well as retailers and pharmaceutical companies. For most, the core business was still in its high-growth phase thanks to one or more breakthrough products or services. Other companies in the top 25 were already growing at a much slower pace than they had in the previous decade but created significant shareholder value by riding out the late stages of their product or service life cycle.
Obviously, management plays a key role in guiding these businesses to innovate and to capture opportunities. But without the undercurrent of real growth in a segment, it becomes very challenging for even a strong management team to deliver outsized performance. Most companies come upon a big idea only once or twice in their entire existence. A global high-tech company, for example, has generated new ideas as its leading breakthrough products slowed down, but the new ones have had a much smaller impact on the overall business. Consequently, the company?s stock performance has lagged behind the market in the past five years. Very few companies have produced a steady stream of new and substantial growth opportunities by aggressively reshaping the business portfolio.
Telecom companies experienced a variation on this pattern during the late 1980s. In the decade after the breakup of AT&T, in 1984, the regional Bell companies that emerged from it enjoyed monopoly power in exchange for universal service access and strict regulatory oversight. By the early 1990s, uncertainty about new technologies and a shift in regulatory philosophy made investors very optimistic about this sector?s growth prospects. Most large telecom companies outperformed the market from 1986 to 1995, first by taking advantage of regulatory protection and then as likely beneficiaries of deregulation. Subsequent events, though, did not unfold as investors expected. The emergence of wireless technology and the Internet forced telecom players to invest heavily at a time when revenues from new products were too small to compensate for the rapid erosion of their traditional revenues.
Extending the business model
A second group of companies, largely in consumer products and pharmaceuticals, outperformed the market by taking advantage of intangible assets such as brands or patents to increase their profit margins and returns on capital. But though owning strong intangible assets was a necessary condition for their performance, it was insufficient on its own. With that as their base, they differentiated themselves from competitors through strategic clarity and consistently strong execution.
As a result, these companies earned high and increasing returns on invested capital: indeed they raised their ROIC by more than 20 percent over the decade, to a ten-year average of 47 percent, compared with an average of 10 percent for the S&P 500. The accumulation of strong brand capital enabled companies in this group to erect effective barriers to price-based competition?barriers that in turn helped them improve their margins constantly. This group of companies also appears to have grown, after adjusting for inflation, at a rate faster than the growth of GDP, probably by taking more market share from competitors.
Rising commodity prices
Many companies owe their sustained outperformance largely to increases in the price of whatever commodities they produce. The price of commodities, such as oil, steel, and commodity chemicals, in turn reflects a number of complex economic, political, and competitive factors beyond the control of most businesses. From the standpoint of fundamental performance, commodity producers do not necessarily stand out: their returns cover their cost of capital but not much more. Their margins remain steady, and their growth is on par with the expansion of real GDP. At the same time, their TRS performance can be volatile as commodity prices swing. The performance of companies in this group of commodity producers may differ widely as a result of the quality of their assets and, to a much lesser extent, of their operating strategies. Over a 40-year period, a majority of commodity players did not outperform the market. Only one of them outperformed it in all four decades.2
Turning around large underperformers
A small group of companies managed to outperform the market over a decade by dramatically improving their hitherto poor operations. These companies, from diverse industries, regained their vigor after a prolonged period of suboptimal performance and margin erosion. Against the backdrop of low market expectations, their operating margins and returns on capital improved substantially?often under the leadership of new managers?which led to better-than-market returns. For this group, revenue and profit growth tended to be lackluster.
For executives at large companies, understanding the limitations of size more fully can better the chances of setting realistic growth aspirations.
Your thoughts matter to others - more than you can imagine.
More Articles published by Albert
54 Free | Ad-Free | Full-Text Business Papers
Finance, Financial ToolsOperational risks are costly, but they can be conquered when high-ranking executives join the battle. 50 | 9.25 K | 15 min
Organisational DevelopmentTalent can be bought, but the best companies develop their own. 50 | 6.17 K | 13 min
Finance, Financial ToolsOf all the findings on business strategy yielded by the study of the businesses in the PIMS? database, the following is one of the most controversial: ... 109 | 6.16 K | 13 min
Knowledge ManagementEmployees' personal connections can be as valuable as their individual knowledge base. Social network analysis, or SNA, helps maximize a company's collective smarts. 50 | 5.01 K | 13 min
Customer Experience ManagementForesee the future, that's what your customers expect, that's what you need to deliver. 65 | 4.32 K | 8 min
Customer Experience ManagementImproving the customer-centricity of your organization isn't just good business, it's also good marketing. 50 | 6.63 K | 5 min
Strategic PlanningGrowth is necessary, but size is no guarantee of a successful future! Nevertheless, growth is needed. Without growth there is no life. In a certain sense, ... 50 | 6.36 K | 11 min
Personal DevelopmentThe global talent war has seen organisational leaders scratching their heads to understand how they can attract and retain the very best talent that is ... 50 | 5.2 K | 9 min
MediaNewspapers have tried a host of measures to halt the long-term decline in their readership, but they haven't stopped consumers from turning to TV and the ... 60 | 17.18 K | 14 min
Sales - GeneralTo get beyond survival and to grow both profits and margins, the successful companies of the future will be forced to become true customer experts. 52 | 5.8 K | 10 min
InternetOrganic search engine optimization has some distinct advantages over pay-per-click advertising. However, there are undoubtedly certain situations and scenarios ... 66 | 4.45 K | 8 min
GlobalisationCompanies based in the GCC states are using their petrodollars to expand into global markets. But in the long run, these companies will have to develop distinctive capabilities and skills. 57 | 6.41 K | 8 min
Trends, FutureGen X-ers want far more collaboration with companies - both as customers and as employees. CIOs are uniquely positioned to help their enterprises meet ... 50 | 4.68 K | 8 min
Performance ManagementServices are more difficult to measure and monitor than manufacturing processes are but executives can rein in variance and boost productivity?if they implement rigorous metrics. 50 | 4.81 K | 16 min
Success BuildingReasons Why You Should Speak at and Attend Professional Seminars 50 | 4.53 K | 11 min
ManagementThe success of strategic investments depends largely on the subsequent moves of competitors. Uncertainty about competitive conduct can lead executives ... 50 | 5.18 K | 9 min
TransformationThe art of leading deep corporate change can be learned. The trick is to help each member of the company discover a new reality... 50 | 27.68 K | 19 min
Trends, FutureHow leading-edge companies are streamlining applications development. 50 | 5.16 K | 17 min
Employee RetentionUS Recruiting, Retaining & Developing Talent Statistics & Best Practises 50 | 7.3 K | 4 min
Negotiation Skills, TechniquesFive easy-to-use tools help negotiators in complex deals arrive at a negotiating position that is not only acceptable to them but also palatable to other ... 50 | 4.53 K | 15 min
Workplace RelatedShould work be fun? Must it be fun? Today, the answer to these questions is mostly yes. What else should it be? Yet however plausible this answer might ... 50 | 6.8 K | 5 min
Strategic Planning"Size is no guarantee of future success." What is strategically important is strength not size. Speed is more important than physical mass and flexibility ... 50 | 5.08 K | 4 min
Success BuildingWhat can Man achieve? What are the limits? 50 | 4.89 K | 5 min
Strategic PlanningBy building social issues into strategy, big companies can recast the debate about their role in society. 79 | 24.9 K | 15 min
TransformationThe CEO helps a transformation succeed by communicating its significance, modeling the desired changes, building a strong top team, and getting personally involved. 50 | 5.92 K | 15 min
FacilitationThe aim of this guide is to prepare you for discussions with a bureau, and to get you thinking about all the factors that affect your Facilitator choice. 50 | 5.76 K | 3 min
Presentation SkillsTrying to perfect a flawless presentation can result in disaster... 50 | 4.81 K | 6 min
StrategyAn organization is much more likely to improve its current performance and underlying health by using a combination of complementary practices rather than ... 50 | 4.28 K | 17 min
ProductivityFor GCC states, liberalizing the labor market and developing the local workforce are the keys to moving beyond a reliance on foreign workers. 66 | 6.41 K | 16 min
Customer Care, ServiceEverything that we do for our clients is based on the idea that improved communications will improve an organisation's performance and contribute to the ... 50 | 5.72 K | 13 min
Team BuildingTwo of today's buzzwords are Team and Teamwork. Those with a particular desire to conform to the spirit of the age portray them as the polar opposite of ... 50 | 9.26 K | 6 min
InspirationalLooking for inspired leadership, passionate employees, unsurpassed productivity, and grateful customers? Forget the dispirited corridors of corporate ... 212 | 29.76 K | 18 min
Customer Care, ServiceOver the last two years of working with hundreds of clients from all walks of life, I have noticed trends of what my clients want and need. This top ten ... 50 | 6.12 K | 3 min
OutsourcingFew companies have the skills to effectively manage procurement across all spending categories. Smart enterprises should examine their procure-ment strategies ... 50 | 5.23 K | 4 min
Human ResourcesSomewhere in Corporate America, a human resources manager is tweaking her company's employee-incentive program. Maybe she's dumping last year's customized ... 60 | 21.08 K | 11 min
Corporate Social ResponsibilityThere appears to be plenty of room for much greater effort and involvement by companies and organizations around the world. Here a few thoughts and pointers. 60 | 813 | 31 min
Succession PlanningSurprisingly, many organizations lack a proper succession plan. One reason is that they do not have an effective succession planning process. This author ... 50 | 8.02 K | 28 min
EthicsRecently, I came across a code of ethics for hackers (yes, it really does exist) that I'd like to share with you, because I think it really hits home with ... 65 | 10.94 K | 4 min
FacilitationValuable insights on using your speaker to maximise the success of your event 50 | 5.77 K | 6 min
ProductivityOver the next two decades, the country's middle class will grow from about 5 percent of the population to more than 40 percent and create the world's fifth-largest consumer market. 55 | 16.2 K | 17 min
GovernanceThe days, weeks, or months between taking the job and assuming power are precious. Put them to good use. 50 | 4.02 K | 13 min
IT - Information TechnologyCompanies that rely on IT governance systems alone will come up short. 50 | 4.1 K | 12 min
Risk ManagementAre you on board with enterprise risk management? You had better be. It's the future of how businesses will be run. 50 | 7.41 K | 21 min
Marketing - GeneralThe proliferation of brands and channels is forcing companies to restructure their marketing efforts significantly. 50 | 5.36 K | 4 min
Lean ManagementLean Thinking is a highly evolved method of managing an organization to improve the productivity, efficiency and quality of its products or services. The ... 51 | 6.76 K | 11 min
Conventions, ConferencesPlenty are the professionals who are on the "front lines" of the industry, knowledgeable of the countless changes, and who are willing and able to speak ... 60 | 4.68 K | 6 min
IT - Information TechnologyEight emerging trends are transforming many markets and businesses. Executives should learn to shape the outcome rather than just react to it. 50 | 15.13 K | 19 min
Project ManagementWhat is success, what is failure, and how can you improve your odds for success? 60 | 23.81 K | 20 min
FacilitationHow do you know if the speaker fits? How do you avoid embarrassing mismatches? 50 | 4.48 K | 4 min
ManagementComplexity has been one of the most frequently used words for some years now. People talk about complex systems, complex interrelationships, complex problems ... 50 | 4.85 K | 9 min
InternetIn 15 seconds, a visitor to your site determines whether or not they are interested in your product or service. Web usability experts can provide all sorts ... 50 | 5 K | 8 min
RelationshipsSometimes we can all use a friendly reminder to keep us from backsliding into old ways of thinking about selling that lead us down the wrong path with potential clients. 50 | 4.67 K | 7 min
LeadershipFurther reform will be essential if one of the world?s fastest-growing regions is to seize a broader role in the global economy 50 | 6.14 K | 15 min
Knowledge ManagementValue created by knowledge is often not captured. Five accounts of knowledge strategies. 50 | 4.9 K | 12 min
More 'Finance, Financial Tools' Articles
4 more Articles that may interest you, too...
By Mark A.
Anti Money Laundry (AML) & Financial Crime Compliance training needs to be more than just facts and a little quiz1.52 K | 50
By Albert E.
Of all the findings on business strategy yielded by the study of the businesses in the PIMS? database, the following is one of the most controversial: Businesses that are highly investment intensive, i.e., those that use high levels of investment per dollar of sales revenue (telecommunications network providers, bulk chemical companies, utilities), are much less profitable than businesses with lower levels of investment per dollar of sales.6.16 K | 109
By Albert E.
Operational risks are costly, but they can be conquered when high-ranking executives join the battle.9.25 K | 50
By Mark A.
Online Anti Money Laundry (AML) courses allow you to tick the boxes on AML but falls well short in terms of learning and skills.1.59 K | 54