Project Agility And Responsiveness - Maintaining The Informal Dimension
Read in 6 min. Traditional, rigorous project management methods are getting more and more insufficient. Business structures have become more ambiguous and fluid as technology has connected people globally. Critical knowledge is often fragmented and mostly available in its tacit form. Social Network Analysis (SNA) is one of the most accurate, systematic means yet seen to identify agile key value creators and informal knowledge structures.
Frank D B.
A Consultant from
Frank D is available for projects both virtually and in-person.
In practice, agility is a careful balance between institutionalised control and carefully choreographed innovative interventions. Particularly in interdisciplinary and geographically-dispersed work settings one has to continuously align to changing situations. In these contexts, situationally specific strategies are often more appropriate than one-size-fits-all approaches.
Because agility cannot be bought or sold, advantage attained through agility is sustainable over time. Nevertheless, unquestioned rigidity, complexity and lack of visibility can prevent projects or organisations from being agile.
Focused collaborative exploration, flexible control strategies and identification of "invisible" informal assets using network analysis techniques can represent suitable approaches to manage these, sometimes interconnected, obstacles.
Collaboration and Knowledge sharing - Cornerstones of agile project management
Collaboration represents a "core managerial competency" and describes the trans-boundary integration of efforts across teams, functions, departments or organisations to achieve common goals. In general, this includes a high degree of communication and shared problem solution processes. One might ask: "Why all this collaboration now"? Business structures, whether formally hierarchical, networked or virtual, have become more ambiguous and fluid as technology has connected people globally. Critical knowledge is often fragmented and is turning more and more into a collective asset.
The transfer of knowledge is an interactive process and the nature of knowledge transfer is affected by the types of relationships people have. Knowledge workers in project teams must be able to navigate through a web of complicated social networks that exist around them, and are often only visible to those who know where to look. The extent that an individual’s "mental knowledge map" matches the actual knowledge network, directly affects their ability to forge relationships, and to gain access to new sources of knowledge. Most extant Knowledge Management approaches rely on static processes as well as on documents indexed by formalized meta-data and additional ontologies. However, these approaches are inadequate for highly dynamic and volatile business environments, whose activities cannot be sufficiently planned in advance and where new, unanticipated "knowledge needs" frequently arise. Such settings demand much more informal documents or artifacts and rely heavily on trustful personal communication between participants.
Cooperative-cum-competitive projects settings - Balancing compliance and commitment
As organisations or project partners engage in a fluidly evolving exchange process, they need adjustable and flexible control strategies. The intention to cooperate is translated into a relational contract that broadly outlines areas of exchange and codes of conduct. Dave Snowden from the Cynefin Centre warns that the formal organisation will always attempt to creep into other spaces through measurement and control, and this partially laudable endeavour needs to be controlled and channelled so that it does not inhibit the capacity of the team or organisation as a whole to develop to meet the demands of its environment.
In this context, Yogesh Malhotra, founder of the BRINT Institute, recognises self-control and commitment as the driver of human actor’s behaviour and actions across instead of emphasising unquestioning adherence to pre-specified rules or procedures. Instead of focusing on "best practices", his model encourages development of a large repertoire of responses to suggest not only alternative solutions, but also different approaches for executing these solutions. The proposed model is based on the premise that "solutions to problems cannot be commanded" [they] must be discovered: found on the basis of imagination, analysis, experiment, and criticism".
Informal networks - The "hidden" power in team-based work settings
People rely very heavily on their network of relationships to find information and solve problems - one of the most consistent findings in the social science literature is that who you know often has a great deal to do with what you come to know. Rob Cross of the University of Virginia points out that just moving boxes on an organisational chart is not sufficient to ensure effective collaboration among high-end knowledge workers. Movement toward de-layered, flexible organisations and emphasis on supporting collaboration in knowledge-intensive work has made it increasingly important for executives and managers to attend to informal networks within their organisations and projects. Communication density and complexity in these networks gets more challenging as the number and diversity of stakeholders (players with a stake in the outcome) grows. Nevertheless, performance implications of effective informal networks with respect to project agility can be significant as the rapidly growing social capital tradition has indicated at the individual, team, and organisational levels. Yet while research indicates ways managers can influence informal networks at both the individual, executives seem to do relatively little to assess and support critical, but often invisible, informal networks in organisations and projects.
Network Analysis techniques - Assessing and maintaining the informal social fabric
Social network analysis (SNA) comprises diagnostic tools that provide managers with both a visual map of the connections among individuals and quantitative data that substantiate the maps and their underlying patterns. Interviews conducted before and after the data gathering analysis ensure that the data are positioned in the context of the project and will not be misinterpreted or misused.
The data gathering and analysis processes provide a baseline against which one can plan and prioritise the appropriate changes and interventions that will increase the social connections within the organization or project - improving communications, knowledge transfer, collaboration, and mutual understanding of shared business goals. Focusing on project agility, SNA is one of the most accurate, systematic means yet seen to identify key value creators and informal knowledge structures that drive responsiveness and organisational core competencies.
Figure 1 pictures an SNA example combining the visualisation of information and knowledge exchange relationships within a virtual project team with the indication of team member’s level of activity or "agility". Project stakeholders of this communal software development initiative are represented by different shapes, whereas the varying geographic locations are highlighted using distinct colours.
The graph clearly shows a separation between central and peripheral team members. In addition, two actors, thus "A33" and "A11" both belonging to the consulting firm, could be identified as most active individuals (indicated by shape size). Focusing on geographic project locations, it came apparent that the strongest relationships (indicated by line thickness) and prominent collaborative activities could be attributed to "City 2" (red colour).
Figure 1: Visualisation of information and knowledge exchange
Your thoughts matter - more than you can imagine.
More Articles by Frank D 1 Free | Ad-Free | Full-Text Business Papers
Collaborate Today And Compete Tomorrow - Managing Key Knowledge In Inter-Organisational Alliances Or NetworksWhen aircraft manufacturer Airbus signed a cooperation deal recently with a visiting Chinese delegation headed by Prime Minister Wen Jiabao commentators ...
More 'Project Management' Articles
12 more Articles that may interest you, too...
When I'm running a Project, I want people to continually remember that we are on this project to achieve.
"Life is too short not to be having fun."
What is success, what is failure, and how can you improve your odds for success?
The Project Manager must be able to have the helicopter view and understand the big picture and how his/her project fits into the overall scheme of things.
"I believe that managing a project without the team co-located , especially if part of the team is working at home, is about as difficult as herding cats."
What is the one thing that most Projects lack? An abundance of time. Most Projects have a very tight schedule and anything that can be done to save time should be done, as long as it doesn't compromise on quality. One thing that can be done is to use the workshop approach when similar information is required from a number of people.
"Knowing what we don't know and tracking it is the only way to ensure that eventually we know what we don't know. Understand?"
Why do IT Teams start building before they have it locked down as to what it is they must build? Let’s take a look at a number of reasons why I think they do.
I believe that a Project Manager should establish an Independent Test Team or an individual on your Project Team with the responsibility of ensuring, through the testing process, that what you are delivering meets the requirements of the client.
Success in PM is more about how you tell em' than what you tell em'.
As a Project Manager, I feel it is important to have someone or some group you can turn to when you need help to get something done either in the client’s, the user’s or the developer’s organisation.